[This blog post is an excerpt from a commentary posted at www.speculative-investor.com last week]
The senior US stock indices have trended upward with only minor pullbacks since April, leaving them very overbought by most measures and at their highest valuations in history. Furthermore, the Russell2000 Small-Cap Index is testing long-term resistance. At the same time, the economy is weakening under the weight of tariffs, regime uncertainty and many years of malinvestment, pointing to either slower earnings growth ahead or earnings contractions if the long-delayed recession finally arrives. Consequently, the current market situation seems precarious.
It is precarious, which is why our own accounts are now about 50% in cash. This is up from 30% in April-2025 and is the highest cash percentage we have had in many years. However, over the past 18 months we have steered clear of bearish speculations in our own accounts and with regard to TSI recommendations/positions (we have not added a stock-market-focussed put option to the TSI List since March-2024).
As an aside, we came close to adding an IWM (Russell2000 ETF) put option to the TSI List in July of this year, but for the option to be added the IWM price had to test resistance at US$230 before reversing downward. It ended up reversing downward from significantly below this resistance and then rebounded off support, prompting us to write (in the 11th August Weekly Update): “…note that a rise by IWM to resistance at $230 now would constitute an upside breakout and would NOT create a buying opportunity for IWM puts.” A week later we went on to explain: “…the small-cap-focussed Russell2000 ETF (IWM) finally attacked resistance at US$230 last week. The resistance has held for now, but the fact that IWM pulled back to support before attacking resistance makes it more likely that the resistance will be breached.” The resistance eventually was breached and a rise to the next important resistance at US$245 soon followed.
Our interest in equity-index-related bearish speculations diminished greatly after we fully understood the reality that with passive investing strategies having come to dominate the market, the traditional mix of equity market fundamentals such as corporate earnings and valuation had all but ceased to matter. In fact, valuation now works in the opposite way, in that the greater the relative overvaluation of a particular stock the larger the proportion of ‘passive’ money that will be allocated to the stock, driving its valuation even higher.
The situation is precarious, because at some point the system that is putting a relentless bid under the market and especially under the stocks with relatively large market capitalisations will go into reverse. At that point and with valuations in the stratosphere, there will be no value-oriented investors to ‘buy the dip’ and most people will be surprised at how far and how fast the market falls.
The system won’t go into reverse because valuations have become too high, because, as explained above, high valuations are not an impediment to demand if most of the demand is ‘passive’. It will go into reverse because the net flow of money into passive funds stops or simply becomes insufficient. This could happen due to the “boomer” generation withdrawing money from their retirement accounts or it could be the result of much higher unemployment (a recession).
Unfortunately, there is no way of predicting when the major reversal point will arrive. At this time we suspect that the overall bullish trend will continue until the end of this year (with a significant intervening correction), but it could continue for much longer than that. In the meantime, we plan to continue doing what we have been doing, which is 1) adjust our overall cash percentage based on short-term risk considerations and 2) find ways to profit on the long side that don’t involve turning a blind eye to the values of underlying businesses. Fortunately, there have been excellent opportunities in the commodity realm over the past 12 months and we expect that there will be many additional opportunities in this realm over the next couple of years.


